Hi @blazer380 , thanks for reaching out to Paid Memberships Pro.
That template is labelled ‘Approvals – Require Approval (admin)’ and should show at the bottom of the list.
This template is sent to the admin for a new pending user – the member does not receive an extra email regarding this.
We are not allowed to support non WordPress.org plugins/premium products on this support channel as it goes against the support guidelines – https://projectdmc.org/support/guidelines/#do-not-post-about-commercial-products
Please can you open a ticket on our website for assistance – https://www.paidmembershipspro.com/supportThank you for understanding.